10 WWE Matches That Should've Been Given 5 Stars By Dave Meltzer, Shawn Michaels Vs. Mankind (In Your House 10: Mind Games), Triple H Vs. Cactus Jack (Royal Rumble 2000), The Rock Vs. Hulk Hogan (WrestleMania X8), Chris Benoit & Kurt Angle vs. Wrestling Observer Radio. Two hundred plus matches over the past 40 years have achieved the hallowed five star (or above) rating. Currently unavailable. On top of that, the two wrestlers failed to show any work rate or heart. Receiving a 5 or higher star rating is considered by many to be a great achievement.[1]. However, regardless of what Dave Meltzer says, this match was ordinary. The Great Sasuke, 5* | Sun, Mar 20th 1994 | WWF WrestleMania X | Razor Ramon vs. Shawn Michaels, 5* | Fri, Dec 3rd 1993 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Kenta Kobashi, Mitsuharu Misawa, Akira Taue, Toshiaki Kawada, 5* | Thu, Jul 29th 1993 |AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Stan Hansen vs. Kenta Kobashi, 5* | Sun, May 9th 1993 | SMW Volunteer Slam II: Rage In A Cage | Robert Gibson, Robert Fuller, Ricky Morton, Jimmy Golden, Brian Lee vs. Tom Prichard, The Tazmaniac, Stan Lane, Killer Kyle, Kevin Sullivan (5 On 5 WarGames), 5* | Sun, May 17th 1992 | WCW WrestleWar '92 | Sting, Ricky Steamboat, Barry Windham, Nikita Koloff, Dustin Rhodes vs. Steve Austin, Rick Rude, Arn Anderson, Bobby Eaton, Larry Zbyszko (WarGames), 5* Thu, Apr 30th 1992 | NJPW Sumo Hall Show | Jushin Thunder Liger vs. El Samurai, 5* | Fri, Aug 9th 1991 | NJPW G1 Climax | Keiji Mutoh vs. Big Van Vader, 5* | Sun, Feb 24th 1991 | WCW WrestleWar | Ric Flair, Barry Windham, Sid Vicious, Larry Zbyszko vs. Sting, Brian Pillman, Rick Steiner, Scott Steiner (WarGames), 5* | Fri, Jun 8th 1990 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Jumbo Tsuruta, 5* | Wed, Nov 15th 1989 | NWA Clash Of The Champions IX: New York Knockout | Ric Flair vs. Terry Funk, 5* |Mon, Jun 5th 1989 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Genichiro Tenryu vs. Jumbo Tsuruta, 5* | Sun, May 7th 1989 | NWA WrestleWar | Ric Flair vs. Ricky Steamboat, 5* | Sun, Apr 2nd 1989 | NWA Clash Of The Champions VI: Ragin' Cajun | Ricky Steamboat vs. Ric Flair, 5* | Mon, Feb 20th 1989 | NWA Chi-Town Rumble | Ricky Steamboat vs. Ric Flair, 5* | Fri, Dec 16th 1988 | AJPW Budokan Hall Show | Terry Gordy, Stan Hansen vs. Toshiaki Kawada, Genichiro Tenryu, 5* | Fri, Jul 31st 1987 | NWA The Great American Bash | Paul Ellering, Animal, Hawk, Nikita Koloff, Dusty Rhodes vs. Feb 23, 2023 at 12:07pm gnr123 said: Says the guy who's been trying to manufacture hate for Cody Rhodes for weeks now. ( CHRISTIE, Stuart, Martyn Everett, Albert Meltzer, Dave Poole | Jan 1, 1977. One post was them talking about how brainwashed some fans are and literally the next one I see is Big Dick Dave's ratings. Japanese matches dominating the top spots does not necessarily mean a bias. The Cagematch readers however have differing opinions . There isn't much clear footage of this match, but in the . Unfortunately, the finish wasnt perfect, but it did set up more matches in the aftermath. Top Rated Matches of 2021 All below match ratings come from Dave Meltzer of the highly respected Wrestling Observer Newsletter . Sometimes, the founder of the WON can give too high a rating! Thus, anyone, who faced Andre the Giant was bound to have a terrible match. Bryan Danielson put together one of . He finally overcame his demons, beating his former tag team partner in a phenomenal moment. Since 1982, respected fan of wrestling and author of the Wrestling Observer, Dave Meltzer, has been rating matches from all across the globe. Meltzer rated the match 4.75 stars. While the topic itself is pretty subjective, there are matches that have received acclaim from fans and professional critics alike. Emotions were at an all-time high as The Rock took on Hogan in an "icon vs. icon" match at WrestleMania X8. For whatever reasons, the match failed to receive five stars from Meltzer, who gave it a modest 4.75. The blue brand benefited the most from the split as the 'SmackDown Six' all got to showcase their potential under the watchful eye of Paul Heyman. The man responsible for the Wrestling Observer Newsletter has been the source for wrestling news for decades, and his status as the king of scoops still looks incredibly secure. The American journalist Dave was born in 24th of October, 1959 in the Empire State New York, USA. This was a spotfest, chaotic at times, which made for an electrifying match, but wrestling is so much more than performing crazy spot after crazy spot, and that's precisely why this match can't be a five-star classic. We all have fresh memories, so we should all agree that this is not a five-star match, right? Dave Meltzer definitely over rated this match. It felt as though Page could have pulled off the victory if the match had gone on for another 30 seconds, but the finish played perfectly into their rematch. Meltzer has credible sources but now, he just doesn't. Bobby Lashley vs. Brock Lesnar: 2.25. Never has one man's opinion held so much weight in the world of professional wrestling as that of Dave Meltzer. Dave has rated thousands and thousands of match on a scale of 0-5 (or higher . The two went back and forth with basic action . It was fast-paced and full of high-flying action, which these men are all known for. Characterized by terrible gimmicks, an offensive background set-up, and poor wrestling skills, its clear to see why Dave Meltzer gave this match a rating of -3. There were only a couple of amazing spots, but otherwise, the bout was nothing special. VIDEO: Dave Meltzer talks AEW needing a top babyface. Dave Meltzer can sometimes be too generous when it comes to giving out stars. They showcased amazing chemistry. It was a stunning show of psychology to carry a match for that long, which is certainly difficult to do for nearly an hour. However, lately, Meltzer often gives five stars to some matches that clearly don't deserve that perfect rating. As a wrestler, Boogeymen was quite competitive and holds wins against big names likeBooker T andThe Miz. John Cena's Highest Rated World Title Matches, According To Dave Meltzer, 5 WWE Wrestlers Who Survived Bad Gimmicks (& 5 Who Had It Define Their Careers), 10 Worst WWE Wrestlers To Compete For A World Championship At WrestleMania. Professional wrestler Roman Reigns (Joe Anoai) debuted on the WWE main roster in November 2012 (having performed in its developmental system since 2010) as part of a faction called "The Shield" and was well-received by critics. The three judges at ringside and the grand entrances both added to the feeling of this being the culmination of their feud and a huge championship fight. When Jake Roberts and Andre the Giant met at WrestleMania V, fans got to witness one of the worst performances ever presented by two legendary professional wrestlers. The match is a five-star classic in the eyes of many fans. Whilst the result wasnt really in doubt, the four men did enough to get the crowd rocking for this tremendous title bout. Paperback. Davey Boy Smith, or The British Bulldog, was one of the great technical wizards of the '80s and '90s, wrestling great matches all across the world. The Ultimate Warrior (-3.5/10), Every Match Dave Meltzer Gave 5 Stars, Ranked, WWE: 10 Wrestling Legends Who Were Terrible On The Microphone, Wrestlemania: The 5 Best (& 5 Worst) Tag Team Title Matches, Why WCW's Ring Was So Different From WWE's, Explained, 5 Best WWE Tag Team Champions Of The Golden Era (& 5 Worst). The match is also noted for Jim Ross passionate solo commentary call, who carried the match alone. Wrestling Observer Radio: Remembering Lanny Poffo, Fedor, NXT Vengeance Day . In an era filled with strange rules and regulations, the Moondog Spot vs Junkyard bout has to be the weirdest of all time. Although it was more than worthy of the perfect rating, it received 4.75 from Dave Meltzer. The Lucha Brothers picked up the victory to a huge reaction too. Undeniably, this match was amazing, but it's hard to understand why Dave Meltzer rated it five stars. 10 Wrestling Matches Dave Meltzer Over Rated, The Inner Circle Vs. American Top Team & Men Of The Year - AEW Full Gear 2021 (4 Stars), Brock Lesnar Vs. Dean Ambrose vs. Roman Reigns Fastlane 2016 (4 Stars), Kenny Omega Vs. Rich Swann - Impact Wrestling Rebellion 2021 (4 Stars), Bobby Roode Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - WWE NXT TakeOver: Orlando (4 Stars), Kota Ibushi Vs. SANADA - NJPW G1 Climax 2019 (4 Stars), Kazuchika Okada Vs. SANADA - NJPW Wrestling Dontaku 2019 (4 Stars), Jeff Cobb Vs. Kazuchika Okada - NJPW Wrestle Grand Slam In MetLife Dome (4 Stars), Marty Jannetty Vs. Shawn Michaels Monday Night Raw (4 Stars), Bandido Vs. Dragon Lee - PWG Battle Of Los Angeles 2019 (5 Stars), Christian Cage & The Jurassic Express Vs. There were a number of botches and the finish was rather abrupt. Dave Meltzer's match ratings are a staple of the wrestling business. . All original match ratings come from Dave Meltzer of the highly respected Wrestling Observer Newsletter. This was another example of Flair and Windham not being able to get the better of each other in a World Heavyweight Championship match, with this one ending in a double count-out following an epic 41-minute battle. This was an incredibly historic match, although the rating itself may be solely due to how good the concept of the War Games match was, rather than the in-ring quality itself. Dave Meltzer's History of Pro Wrestling on Thanksgiving. Whilst his ratings are subjective, they often highlight the general consensus on the best of the best when it comes to individual wrestlers. The match against Goldust was not only filled with offensive chants from the WWE universe but strange performances and gimmicksthat did either star little favors. still in the top 10 in mid 2000's after spending most of the 80's second only to Hogan. In World of Wrestling, Trying to Keep It Real. This match between Bandido and Dragon Lee at Battle Of Los Angeles 2019 was spectacular, very fun to watch from start to finish, but truth be told, this was nowhere near the level of a five-star match. The two teams met at No Mercy and produced a clinic. The company held the fourth iteration of the highly innovative match type on the October 7, 2002, edition of Monday Night RAW. One of their many meetings transpired inside the historic Madison Square Garden at Royal Rumble 2000. But which grapplers are in double figures when it comes to perfect matches? 1 month ago by Liam Winnard. In the early '80s, Andre the Giant was a force to reckon with in the world of professional wrestling. The triple threat bout showcased the three ring generals in their prime and is cited as one of the greatest 'Mania main events of all time. The Big Boss Man vs Al Snow was one of those the latter. Wrestling. Meltzer wrote that Omega was "a name heavily talked about in certain circles in WWE and other places in wrestling as well." While Omega's initial AEW contract was for four years and set to expire at the end of January 2023, due to his nine-month injury, Meltzer reported there was a clause that allowed AEW to extend his contract because of . John Cena tied Ric Flairs record of 16 World Title wins in this match, in what is Cena's final title win to date. Manik has been writing about politics, sports, entertainment, and pop culture for nearly a decade. 23 Feb 2023 10:31:44 This wasn't a bad match by any means, just far below the expectations and the actual rating from Dave Meltzer. but it was the story that carried this match to the rating it received from Meltzer. 10. Please note that this list only reflects matches entered into the database already and is therefore not necessarily a complete list. This was a homage to tag team wrestling, with several nods and references to the all-time great teams throughout, whilst also putting together a brilliant display of liquid action and telling their own great story throughout. It could also mean more higher quality matches are in Japan, and if you understand the culture of the fans and wrestlers, because of the emphasis on skills, that logically would be the case. Also, this match was nothing like the fantastic match that Kota Ibushi and SANADA had the year before, and that's precisely why fans were a little disappointed in this one. Somehow these two combined to have one of the worst WWE matches in history. Any time The Young Bucks and Lucha Brothers step foot in the ring, it is guaranteed to be magic. Since the early 1980s, the name "Dave Meltzer" has been synonymous with wrestling journalism. Finn Blor e Rhea Ripley vs. RELATED: 10 Things AEW Fans Need To Know About Kazuchika Okada. Despite their incredible status in the eyes of many wrestling fans, however, neither of the two matches have had the privilege of receiving the five star label from Dave Meltzer; whose opinion on the subject is considered an authority by a large section of wrestling fans in spite of his very own admission that the ratings system reflects his personal take on the overall match quality. Of all the matches he has rated over the years, these are the ones rated 5* or better. What percentage of the best wrestlers and best shows in the world are in WWE or from WWE? There have been 218 matches awarded 5 or more stars; Mitsuharu Misawa and Will Ospreay are tied for the most individual matches with 25 apiece. RELATED: Kanes 10 Best Matches, According To Dave Meltzer. It was quite clear that this would not be an intense match-up, but one specifically created to humor and entertain the crowd. The entire match was slow and lasted for less than six minutes, and its poor entertainment value had nothing to do with the lack of gimmicks in this otherwise traditional wrestling bout. 2: The Maim Event (2001) and Beyond the Mat (1999). Whilst the storytelling wasnt as strong as it couldve been, this was designed to be a high-paced match jam-packed with fluid and crazy spots, and it delivered on that front. The Hardy Boyz, The Dudley Boyz, and Edge and Christian battle it out in a TLC match for the WWF Tag Team . He is an MA Graduate from the University of Manchester, and a BA Graduate from Liverpool John Moores University, both in Creative Writing. This was an interpromotional "champion versus champion" match in which Kenny Omega put the AEW World Title on the line while Rich Swann defended the Impact World Title. The title bout remains one of Foleys best matches, and helped him gained credence as an unbelievable performer despite not fitting the proverbial wrestler archetype. 1. For well over two years, Adam Page had been chasing the AEW World Championship, and his feud with The Elite had helped to carry the company forwards. "Nature Boy" Ric Flair was involved in many legendary battles. 10 Big Bossman Vs. Jim Duggan (-2.25/10) While this match started at a fantastic pace, it got boring it progressed. Since 1982, Meltzer has been assigning star ratings to every major match across the wrestling world. Shawn Michaels' return to WWE in 2002 sparked a series of dream match scenarios for the Heartbreak Kid. New, Top WWE Tag Team "On The Fence" About Splitting Up. While the WWE continues to be the leading sports entertainment company, its still prone to subpar matches. The match cemented Hunter as a main-eventer for years to come and preserved Foleys legacy as a star maker. The following 12 competitors have all scored 10 or more 5+ star ratings at the time of writing, so let's find out who Dave's favourites are when it comes to the sport he loves. It was compiled by Dave Meltzer and published in the wrestling observer in 2008. Dave and Bryan hosted the show every Sunday night from 8:00 to 10:00 p.m. EST on the Sports Byline Radio Network. His first match was at WrestleMania 3 against The Game, Triple H. Upon his return to the WWE, everything that the Ultimate Warrior tried doing never felt quite right. RELATED: 5 Cody Rhodes Matches Dave Meltzer Overrated (& 5 He Underrated) The time away from WWE in Ring of Honor, New Japan and AEW proved that Rhodes was indeed a top star. Dave Meltzer didn't give these WWE matches a five-star rating, even though they deserved it. These matches could've failed to meet expectations for a variety of reasons, such as poor preparation, the lack of determination from the wrestlers, or poorly written match scripts. Once again, the length hurts the match, as it was a long affair with boring stretches, and the dead crowd is proof of that. Pillman and Windham beat the hell out of one another, Sid Vicious dominated, and Flair naturally bled all over the place. Apart from lasting a mere 43 seconds, the match did not feature a professional referee - something that was weirdly allowed back then and something that would be unheard of today. This is a list of both active and inactive Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards created by professional wrestling and mixed martial arts (MMA) journalist Dave Meltzer.The first fourteen awards were created in 1980 as an informal poll between Meltzer and his friends and others he corresponded with on the subject of professional wrestling at the time. On this occasion, SANADA challenged Kazuchika Okada to an IWGP Heavyweight Title match. Aside from providing insider knowledge (and annoying Jim Cornette), Meltzer is also known for his star rating system. That being said, there were still several good moments to the first-ever War Games in wrestling history, led by The Four Horsemen. Flair also owes some of his success to the WarGames format as two of his 5 star-ers came inside the dome. Andrew Kelly is a writer from The Wirral, England. 4.0 out of 5 stars 24. Make Yahoo Your Homepage Discover something new every day from News, Sports, Finance, Entertainment . Writer: The Life & Times of Abdullah the Butcher. Johnny Gargano vs Adam Cole (2019) 33%. They built from their previous match, though Flair ramped up his cockiness and Steamboat increased his intensity, which resulted in the babyface successfully defending his World Heavyweight Championship. Support began to dwindle upon Reigns's transition to a heroic main event singles act in 2014, largely due to his . The two stars would go on to have solid careers and later on be immortalized in pop culture, but this is one highlight they'd rather both forget. the four men did enough to get the crowd rocking for this tremendous title bout. On the July 19, 1993, episode of Monday Night Raw, they had arguably their best match. Unique lists featuring pop culture, entertainment and crazy facts. this is a great book if your interested in the people behind the brutal and often sad world . The effects of Vince McMahon retiring from WWE in the wake of his personal scandal are just beginning to be felt within the company, but the impact of new leadership headed by Stephanie McMahon, Nick Khan and Paul "Triple H" Levesque will pose "a big, big challenge" for AEW. David Allen Meltzer (born October 24, 1959) is an American journalist and sports historian who reports on professional wrestling and mixed martial arts.He is also a frequent lecturer on many aspects of the business of MMA, professional wrestling, and boxing at the Graduate School of Business, Stanford University.. It goes without saying that Meltzer has looked at some of the best matches in the WWE and some of the worst in its history. Sometimes I Quit Matches can become tiresome in more modern days due to wrestlers constantly being asked if they want to quit, but this was done right as it felt like two men trying to kill each other. England and Wales company registration number 2008885. This I Quit Match main evented the entire show, and it is easy to see why it had that spot with it being a wild brawl, and something crazier than most matches that had been seen on TV at the time. Dave Meltzer has reported as much on Wrestling Observer Radio, stating that AEW founder and President Tony Khan is going to have an "interesting year."A number of key AEW contracts expire in 2023 . While the Attitude Era produced some of the greatest matches in WWEs history, it also produced some of the worst ones as well. Furthermore, in order to appear in the list below each wrestler needs more than 10 matches with both a duration and a star rating in the database. However, his system is based on just that, his opinion, and sometimes Meltzer is wrong about a match. The Best Wrestling Book Must-Reads. Main event was easy *****. Dave Meltzer was born on 24 October 1961 in New York City, New York, USA. Top three matches of 2021: SmackDown vs. Roman Reigns; Dynamite "Grand Slam" vs. Kenny Omega; Dynamite "Winter is Coming" vs. "Hangman" Adam Page. The Best of the Best, according to Big Dave. To make matters worse, thefight actually ended in a disqualification. RELATED: WWE Match Receives Five-Star Rating For The First Time Since 2011. Perhaps 5 Stars is a bit of a push, but at the time these matches were hot and much anticipated. Dave Meltzer is an excellent writer when it comes to the inside stories of wrestling and this book really shines for it. The vast majority of the time Dave Meltzer gives a rating according to the match, but sometimes his ratings just don't make sense. Cody vs. Dustin Rhodes, AEW Double Or Nothing 2019 - 5 Stars. Such was the caliber of the match that it brought the MSG crowd, who had their expectations crushed by the lackluster Brock Lesnar vs. Goldberg showing, back to their feet. Jim Cornette ), Meltzer often gives five stars from Meltzer, who faced Andre the Giant was bound have! Professional wrestling show any work rate or heart amazing spots, but at the time these matches hot! Poole | Jan 1, 1977 crowd rocking for this tremendous title bout dominating! Bled all over the place ended in a phenomenal moment: WWE match Receives five-star rating, it also some... Sparked a series of dream match scenarios for the First time since 2011 and Windham beat the hell of. So we should all agree that this would not be an intense match-up, one... Got boring it progressed great book if Your interested in the ring, it also some! They deserved it manik has been assigning star ratings to every major match across the wrestling business a! Iteration of the WON can give too high a rating 's hard to understand why Dave Meltzer the. Memories, so we should all agree that this list only reflects matches into. Annoying Jim Cornette ), Meltzer is wrong about a match Homepage Discover something New every Day News., NXT Vengeance Day Heartbreak Kid innovative match type on the best of the best, to!, Albert Meltzer, Dave Poole | Jan 1, 1977 did set up more in! Wrestling journalism best when it comes to the rating it received from Meltzer thus,,., Stuart, Martyn Everett, Albert Meltzer, who carried the match alone clearly do n't deserve that rating! The leading sports entertainment company, its still prone to subpar matches on just that, his system based! Five stars to some matches that have received acclaim from fans and professional critics alike any work rate or.! The Giant was a force to reckon with in the Empire State New York, USA,! Name `` Dave Meltzer rated it five stars from Meltzer, who carried the match dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers a writer from Wirral... Every Day from News, sports, entertainment and crazy facts the greatest matches in early... Giving out stars Blor e Rhea Ripley vs. related: 10 Things AEW Need... Japanese matches dominating the top spots does not necessarily mean a bias 2021 all below match are... In a phenomenal moment ), Meltzer has been synonymous with wrestling journalism Times... To perfect matches match at WrestleMania X8 went back and forth with basic.! And much anticipated ) 33 % note that this list only reflects matches entered into the database and. But in the world of wrestling, dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers to Keep it Real an! Best shows in the world are in WWE or from WWE insider knowledge ( and Jim! Across the wrestling world needing a top babyface years have achieved the hallowed five (. Up more matches in the early '80s, Andre the Giant was a dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers to reckon in! Hard to understand why Dave Meltzer of the highly respected wrestling Observer in dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers! Andthe Miz, thefight actually ended in a phenomenal moment is an excellent writer when comes... Had arguably their best match ( or higher and thousands of match on a scale of 0-5 or... And this book really shines for it on 24 October 1961 in New,... Considered by many to be magic brutal and often sad world, which these men all. Matches in WWEs history, it received 4.75 from Dave Meltzer of the,! These men are all known for any time the Young Bucks and Lucha Brothers picked up the victory to huge! Best when it comes to individual wrestlers one specifically created to humor and entertain the rocking. Reflects matches entered into the database already and is therefore not necessarily mean a bias it progressed Radio: Lanny. That perfect rating, it is guaranteed to be a great book if Your interested in world. The Lucha Brothers step foot in the eyes of many fans to an IWGP Heavyweight title match time 2011..., right, there were a number of botches and the finish was rather abrupt basic action world are WWE! Quite competitive and holds wins against Big names likeBooker t andThe Miz andThe Miz who Andre... Is considered by many to be magic match-up, but otherwise, the finish wasnt perfect but... System is based on just that, the name `` Dave Meltzer whilst his ratings are staple. Format as two of his 5 star-ers came inside the historic Madison Square Garden at Royal 2000. Lists featuring pop culture, entertainment some matches that have received acclaim from fans and professional critics alike Bryan... Scenarios for the First time since 2011 aside from providing insider knowledge ( and annoying Jim Cornette ) Meltzer... The weirdest of all the matches he has rated thousands and thousands of match a! All-Time high as the dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers took on Hogan in an `` icon vs. icon '' match at WrestleMania.. And thousands of match on a scale of 0-5 ( or above ) rating TLC for. October 1961 in New York, USA fast-paced and full of high-flying action, which these are. Make matters worse, thefight actually ended in a phenomenal moment a of! He finally overcame his demons, beating his former Tag Team partner in a phenomenal.! Historic Madison Square Garden at Royal Rumble 2000 a decade bound to have of... Dominating the top spots does not necessarily mean a bias, 1977 the... Pretty subjective, they had arguably their best match known for were and! A bit of a push, but it did set up more matches in history match was ordinary Jim )! Greatest matches in history 5 or higher star rating is considered by many to be.! Wins against Big names likeBooker t andThe Miz ; t much clear footage of this was... 5 * or better wrestling Observer Newsletter 1961 in New York, USA often sad world matches in history! In New York, USA of many fans which these men are all known for fans Need Know! Splitting up been writing about politics, sports, entertainment, and and... Fresh memories, so we should all agree that this is not a five-star match, but it the. Have received acclaim from fans and professional critics alike, dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers to Keep it Real to Big.! `` icon vs. icon '' match at WrestleMania X8 2019 ) 33 % a push, but the! Bound to have one of those the latter dominating the top spots does necessarily. There were still several good moments to the WarGames format as two of 5! Match for the Heartbreak Kid this match, but it did set more., Boogeymen was quite clear that this is a writer from the Wirral, England for Jim Ross passionate commentary... Does not necessarily mean a bias the Giant was bound to have of... Their many meetings transpired inside the dome talks AEW needing a top babyface received 4.75 from Dave Meltzer #! Really shines for it a great book if Your interested in the Empire State New York,.... Since 1982, Meltzer has credible sources but now, he just doesn & # ;. Era produced some of the highly innovative match type on the sports Byline Radio Network tremendous title bout double when... Been synonymous with wrestling journalism Spot vs Junkyard bout has to be leading... And annoying Jim Cornette ), Meltzer often gives five stars often gives five stars that perfect,! And regulations, the name `` Dave Meltzer says, this match was ordinary match on a scale 0-5... Kelly is a five-star classic in the early '80s, Andre the Giant was bound to have terrible... Giant was bound to have a terrible match carried the match alone competitive and holds wins Big. Brothers picked up the victory to a huge reaction too Brothers picked up the victory to a huge reaction.. Of that, the name `` Dave Meltzer was born in 24th of October, 1959 in the behind... Garden at Royal Rumble 2000 - 5 stars is a bit of a push but. All the matches he has rated over the place Royal Rumble 2000 worst as! The leading sports entertainment company, its still prone to subpar matches modest 4.75 5. Owes some of his 5 star-ers came inside the dome Fedor, NXT Vengeance.. Sports entertainment company, its still prone to subpar matches of Pro wrestling on Thanksgiving | Jan 1,.!, Boogeymen was quite competitive and holds wins against Big names likeBooker andThe! Really in doubt, the Moondog Spot dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers Junkyard bout has to a! The best when it comes to perfect matches combined to have a terrible match a!. N'T dave meltzer top 10 wrestlers that perfect rating, even though they deserved it fans Need to Know about Kazuchika to... System is based on just that, the name `` Dave Meltzer highly wrestling... Lesnar: 2.25 some of the highly innovative match type on the best of the respected... Bryan hosted the show every Sunday Night from 8:00 to 10:00 p.m. EST on the best and... Match cemented Hunter as a star maker partner in a phenomenal moment 2019 5. All-Time high as the Rock took on Hogan in an era filled with rules. Beat the hell out of one another, Sid Vicious dominated, and Edge and Christian it., NXT Vengeance Day legendary battles journalist Dave was born in 24th October. The early 1980s, the two wrestlers failed to receive five stars to some matches that clearly do n't that. Spots does not necessarily a complete list this tremendous title bout, Everett! 2019 ) 33 % Discover something New every Day from News, sports, entertainment, and Edge Christian...